25 April 2021
Sector: Enterprise
Focus: Consulting, Website Design & Development
Situation
The RFP asked vendors for everything at once, demos rewarded theatre, and internal stakeholders measured success differently. Without alignment upfront, selection turns into a beauty contest followed by regret.
What we focused on
- Weighted criteria: Editor UX, integrations, TCO, and migration risk, explicitly traded off.
- Proof tasks: Scenarios vendors had to reproduce in a follow-up, not slide promises.
- Decision memo: One-page rationale finance and IT could sign, reducing revisit every quarter.
Outcome
A decision that survived leadership change and a roadmap that didn’t assume infinite implementation budget.